Use of facial recognition in schools. DPIA’s are essential.

by | Apr 23, 2025 | Uncategorized

Use of facial recognition in schools. DPIA's are essential.

Facial Recognition – DPIA’s are essential

North Ayrshire council was criticised for attempting to introduce facial recognition technology so that pupils can pay for school meals in an attempt to speed up service and to reduce the risk of spreading Covid-19 via pin pads or fingerprint recognition.

However, the authority came under fire from privacy campaigners and the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) stepped in.
The council stated that the “facial registrations” are encrypted and cannot be used by another agency, and when the student leaves school or opts out of the system, they will be deleted.” And that it added : “Facial recognition has been assessed as the optimal solution that will meet all our requirements.”
Many parents questioned its use and said that the phrasing of the consent that they were asked to give for its use wasn’t “freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject’s wishes..”
Concerns have also been raised previously about facial recognition technology because it frequently misidentifies women and people of colour.
Significantly, the biometrics company refused to disclose who else children’s personal information could be shared, which should certainly ring alarm bells.
In response to the queries, the ICO commented that “Data protection law provides additional protections for children, and organisations need to carefully consider the necessity and proportionality of collecting biometric data before they do so,” an ICO spokesperson told the Guardian.
“Organisations should consider using a different approach if the same goal can be achieved in a less intrusive manner. We are aware of the introduction, and will be making inquiries with North Ayrshire council.”
This prompted the Council to suspend the initiative.
The matter highlights a few things:
  • Firstly, whilst the Council claims it was an appropriate system to use, each school should conduct their own Data Protection Impact Assessment to prove that they are satisfied with the features of the product. 
  • Also it is important to understand that the UK GDPR is in place to protect the individual not an organisation, and the individual’s protection should be paramount. Not knowing things such as exactly where personal data is stored or with whom it is being shared are unacceptable. 
Cyber Essentials

Cyber Essentials

Is it worth all the hassle and cost As outsourced DPOs for a number of schools, we have spent a great deal of time advising clients to gain Cyber Essential accreditation. We are well aware that it is not the highest level of IT security accreditation but it does...

New ICO Surveillance Guidance

New ICO Surveillance Guidance

New ICO guidance for Video Surveillance The ICO has published guidance on the processing of personal data by video surveillance systems, click here to go to the ICO website  The guidance outlines how data protection principles must be complied with when using certain...

Privacy Snakes and Ladders

Privacy Snakes and Ladders

Play this game to learn how to make smart privacy choices We would like to thank our friends at the “Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada for sharing these great games. How to play activity sheet You need a game piece for every player and a die. The person who...